Once, I was at
a shul on Yom Tov. The Rav invited a guest speaker to speak between Mincha and Maariv.
The speaker prefaced his remarks by saying that this shiur needed an
hour to be delivered properly. He expressed regret that he only had 15 minutes
but assured us he would do his best to give us an appreciation for his vital
message.
After
15 minutes, he was still just getting started. He kept going. People started
shifting in their seats, but he pressed on, clearly passionate about his topic.
He reiterated how crucial the idea he was sharing was. After half an hour,
people looked at their watches. The speaker remained focused on delivering his
message. At 45 minutes, some people walked out, and the Rav of the shul
nervously glanced at his watch.
Finally,
the speaker himself noticed the time. After he recovered from his initial
shock, he commented, “Well, this shiur is so important that I will just
have to keep going!” After an hour, he finally completed the shiur. He
was satisfied that he had delivered his message properly, though he failed to
abridge it.
The
speaker left satisfied, but from observing the audience, it seemed not everyone
shared that sentiment. Personally, while I appreciated his enthusiasm, I found
it hard to stay engaged when the talk ran much longer than expected. In fact,
my frustration with the extended length made it harder for me to fully embrace
his message, even though I’m sure it was well-intentioned.
Although
this true anecdote may sound exaggerated, I believe that many of us, with the
best of intentions, sometimes approach life the way that speaker did. We have
our own vision and agenda, and that often blinds us to others’ sensitivities.
I
sometimes wish that I could watch a video recording of my day. I’m sure I would
pick up on so many of my blind spots if I could view myself from an outsider’s
perspective. Being bound to our own world makes it hard to let anything else
register on our radar. Yet I do think we can train ourselves to succeed in this
area. We should start by picking up on other people’s subtle and not-so-subtle
cues.
I
once wanted to give someone constructive criticism. I went over to him and
asked, “Can I tell you something?” He sensed from my tone of voice that it wasn’t
something he wanted to hear, and he responded, “No.” However, I was so
passionate about what I wanted to share that I told him anyway! Looking back,
it was a learning experience. I realized that focusing so much on my own
intention made me miss his clear message that he wasn’t interested in the
conversation. From this I learned how important it is to balance passion with
sensitivity and that every situation can help us grow in understanding others.
Most
scenarios aren’t as extreme or confrontational. But if we become attuned to the
cues that others give us, we can become more sensitive to their experience. If
I am saying something and the listener rolls his eyes, yawns often, looks
distracted, or responds harshly, these are usually indications that he doesn’t
appreciate or isn’t interested in what I have to say. Or it can indicate that
now is not a good time to have this conversation.
I
want to share a technique that I use when giving a shiur. Although I
focus on what I am saying, I also pay attention to the audience’s eyes and
facial cues. I can tell when they are engaged, and I try to pick up when they
are not. If they are not engaged, I might tell a joke or digress into a story
to bring them back in.
I
can often tell when the audience understands what I have shared and when they
are struggling to understand. In the latter scenario, which can happen in a
complicated Talmudic discussion, I often skip the next part of the shiur
I had prepared if it would confuse them even more. It’s not easy for a speaker
to skip part of a prepared speech, especially if he worked hard on it and wants
to share new insights. I have to remind myself that what I am excited about isn’t
always what my students will enjoy.
This
applies to interpersonal relationships, as well. We need to learn to pick up on
whether someone seems hurt or angry by something we say or do. I want to
illustrate this with the classic case of a wife, looking for empathy,
complaining to her husband, while her husband gives her a solution to her
problem. The husband feels he did exactly what was expected of him, yet the
wife feels alone and unsupported. My wife and I regularly joke about this
repetitive dynamic.
Recently,
after I “solved” one of my wife’s complaints about a construction project in
our home, I reflected on our conversation. It dawned on me that, despite my
sage advice and Herculean efforts to reach the contractor immediately and resolve
her problem, her face didn’t show the unconstrained gratitude I expected. In
fact, she seemed to get more stressed as my efforts on her behalf progressed. In
hindsight, I was frustrated with myself for getting so caught up in solving the
“problem” that I failed to notice the facial and vocal cues she was sending.
She hadn’t come for a solution; she had come for support!
As
you can probably tell, I am not sharing these insights with you as someone who
has mastered the skill of sensitivity to others’ feelings and cues. Rather, I’m
sharing these as someone who is on a journey to grow in this area, and I hope
to offer insights from my experiences along the way. My hope is to raise
awareness that although it’s easy to overlook the experiences and messages of
those around us, with effort and reflection, we can all make meaningful
progress. This awareness is a powerful first step toward positive growth.
Rabbi Dovid Jaffee is a beis medrash magid shiur and author. His audio shiurim about personal growth and other topics are available on shasilluminated.org. To contact Rabbi Jaffee for private consultations or speaking engagements, email rabbidovidjaffee@gmail.c





