by Ron and Myrna Mitnick
When we made aliyah at the
end of 2015, we did renovations to our apartment, which we had purchased a
couple of years prior. Our general contractor asked us if we had family in
Israel. We responded in the negative; we explained that all of our children and
grandchildren live in the U.S. He asked (conversation translated from Hebrew),
“So, why did you come? Zionism?” When we answered in the affirmative, he said,
“Interesting. I did not know that spirit was still alive.”
We both became interested in living
in Israel when we studied in Israel in our late teens. Myrna studied at
Michlalah Yerushalayim, and Ron studied at Yeshivat HaNegev in Netivot, between
Beersheva and Gaza. Both of us had significant contact with Israelis; Myrna
lived with Israeli roommates, and Ron’s yeshiva was Israeli, with only a small
number of English speakers. Each of us was only here for a year, but the
experience was intense, memorable, and impacted us on a very deep level. We
sensed that something special was happening in Israel, namely the return of the
Jewish people to its G-d-given Land.
From when we met a couple of years
after our studies through our years as newlyweds, we would talk about Israel. However,
in that phase of our life, economic and family considerations ruled out making aliyah.
Admittedly, there was some jealousy when a couple of close friends made the big
move in the 1980s, but eventually we stopped talking about it as it were just a
faraway dream.
While Israel remained in our
consciousness, we were busy raising a family, and with our parents’ ages
advancing, we remained in Baltimore. For 20 years after we studied in Israel,
we did not travel there. Then, an opportunity presented itself to reconnect
with Israel through a tour organized by the Eretz Israel Movement. Our oldest
daughter would be attending seminary starting in September, so we travelled as
a family to Israel for the tour and left our daughter for her year of study. That
trip initiated a series of periodic trips to Israel, and the feelings of love
for Israel, our Homeland, were ever increasing. Two of our trips were made to
participate in the ALYN Hospital fundraising bicycle rides, each of which
covered about 250 miles over five days and gave us a chance to see the Land up
close. One of the rides was in the south, another in the north, so we covered
quite a lot of the country. Due to the wonderful generosity of our friends, we
were able to raise significant funds for the hospital.
*
* *
“Dor holeich vedor ba” (a generation passes and another
comes). By the end of 2012, when our children were young adults and we
no longer had living parents, we began to think more seriously about aliyah.
At first, we decided to buy an apartment, not necessarily to live in, but at
least to “own a piece of the rock.” We selected Modi’in for several reasons: We
have first cousins who live in Reut, which has been annexed to Modi’in; Modi’in
would be more accessible to Ron’s prospective employment sites near the
Mediterranean coast; we liked the demographic variety that Modi’in offers; and
it was and is a new, well-planned city with lots of green space. Within about a
year, our cousin found the apartment to which we would eventually make aliyah.
One of the things we like about the apartment is the great view of the Emek
Ayalon and Shaalbim (now known as Sha’alvim), both of which are mentioned in Sefer
Yehoshua, among other places in Tanach.
Our plan was to rent the apartment
to others for an indefinite period of time and eventually make aliyah. However,
owning an apartment created a strong magnetic pull, and soon our timeframe for
moving shortened. Another factor played a role as well. We were receiving a
newsletter via email every week, the “Israel Good News” newsletter. Every week,
we would read about the miraculous achievements, medical and technological
discoveries, and lifesaving aid Israel provides all over the world.1
It became very clear to us that Hashem is chonen da’at, bestowing
wisdom, big time, on the citizens of Israel. It was also clear that
Jewish history is being made in Israel, and Jews outside of Israel are, to use
a sports metaphor, fans in the stands.
Around February of 2015, while we
were getting more serious about aliyah, there was a Nefesh B’Nefesh
event in Baltimore, which Ron attended – and he won the raffle for a free pilot
trip to Israel! Our reaction was that we should “listen to our messages,”2
and our aliyah planning accelerated. We will skip over most of the
details that led up to our aliyah in November, 2015. One point we would
like to make is that this decision surprised our children quite a bit! While
they knew of our feelings about Israel, we hadn’t spoken much about actually
making aliyah, so this news was a bolt from the blue. We have great
relationships with our children, and since they are all in the U.S., it was
completely unexpected. Reactions at that time varied from very supportive, to
less supportive, to hurt. But, returning to the “fans in the stands”
comparison, more and more, we wanted to have our moment on the field and get a
few touches of the ball. So, up we went in the fall of 2015.
*
* *
It must be said up front that aliyah
today is very different from when our longtime friends made aliyah back
in the 1980s and 1990s. Back then, international telephone conversations were
very expensive, as was air travel between the U.S. and Israel. Thus, when
someone made aliyah, you would rarely, if ever, hear from them or see
them. Also, Israel at that time lacked the feel of a first world country,
partially because it was a socialist country with the resultant suppressed
economic growth. Of course, none of that is true today. Communications
technology is such that we can be in touch with our family in the U.S. anytime
we want to be. And while we became somewhat spoiled before Covid, with round-trip
airline fares of less than $1,000, the fares are still much more reasonable
than they were back in the day.
Nevertheless, the first couple of
years of our aliyah were an adjustment for us and our families. Having
been active in the lives of our children and grandchildren, especially those
living in Baltimore, we missed them a lot. It is not that we do not miss them
now when we are in Israel, but when the situation was new, the feelings were
raw. There were days when we felt shipwrecked on an uncharted island and
wondered why we were in Israel. And judging from our tears and the tears of our
children when we would say goodbye before heading back to Israel from our
visits to the States, we believe that it was hard for them as well.
While we had occasional doubts
about leaving the family for aliyah, it has become easier over the
years. In truth, it is still sometimes difficult on chagim, when we do
not have our immediate family members with us in Israel. As time has passed,
however, it seems that the family gets chizuk from having
parents/grandparents in Israel. For example, one day, one of our young
grandsons called excitedly on the telephone and said, “I was just learning Nach
with Tatty, and we just read about the Emek Ayalon, which you see from your
balcony!” As some of the grandchildren are old enough to come here on their own
for visits or to study in Israel, the family benefits from our providing an
open, welcoming door. Of course, that door is open for our children as well. An
added perk is that one of our granddaughters and her family now live in
Yerushalayim. Most importantly for maintaining our family ties, we spend plenty
of time in Baltimore during the year, for both professional reasons and family
events. Im ayin hatov, we have numerous family smachot for which
we return to the U.S., and we try to attend all of them if possible. No, we are
not able to attend every siddur play, Bais Yaakov exhibit, or JFL game,
but we try to hear as much as we can about these events when we connect with
the family.
*
* *
Why do we stay? First and foremost,
we believe this is the Land that Hashem gave us, and He is looking for our
hishtadlut (personal efforts) to enable Him to bring all of our people back
to our Land. By being here and observing Hashem’s mitzvot in the place where Hashem
intended for them to be performed, we feel like we are doing something
transcendent every day.3
We belong to a wonderful shul,
Kehillat Shaarei Yonah Menachem (KSYM). It is the largest synagogue in Modi’in,
and one of a handful based on nusach Ashkenaz. In terms of programming,
it is modeled after Diaspora kehillot, meaning it is a full-service
community and not just a place to pray. There are many oleh families in
KSYM, with more joining every year. The olim are primarily English
speakers from the U.S., U.K., Australia, and South Africa. We feel very
privileged to daven with our fellow congregants because all of them have
been moser nefesh, self-sacrificing, to a great degree. All of them came
from better physical circumstances, and many have had to switch gears
professionally, which can be very challenging. But much more difficult than
that, almost all of the congregants believe in serving in the IDF to protect
our people in the milchemet mitzvah (obligatory war, the participation
in which is halachically mandated) in which we have been engaged for over three
years.4 On October 8, 2023, over 180 of our congregants’
children were either already serving or were called up to milu’im,
reserve duty. Many of these were frontline soldiers seeing combat in Gaza for
extended periods of time. As the war widened, some saw action in Lebanon and
Syria as well. Almost all these brave young men and women have had to be away
from their families and to repeatedly into harm’s way. It is humbling for us to
have the zechut to daven side-by-side with these examples of such true mesirut
nefesh.
We are most fortunate to have as
our rav, Rav Shlomo Sobol. Rav Sobol learned and earned smicha from
Yeshivat Mercaz HaRav Kook. He and his wife, Tali, were shlichim in
Detroit for a few years, so they have familiarity with American Orthodoxy and
can relate well to the olim to our community. Rav Sobol also has
facility in English, although the vast majority of his shiurim and
interactions are in Hebrew. Rabbi Sobol is an expert in Shas and poskim,
as well as the writings of HaRav Avraham Yitzchak HaKohen Kook and Tanya. Rav
Sobol codirects an organization, Barkai, whose goal is to train Israeli rabbis
to provide pastoral services similar to those provided by rabbis in chutz
la’aretz.
The Sobols believe with every fiber
of their being that we are witnessing kibbutz galui’ot (ingathering of
exiles) and the process of the ultimate geulah. Their passion for
this belief reinforces our appreciation of the miraculous times in which we are
living. Rav Sobol also acts as a chaplain for the IDF. Since the onset of the
war, we have often seen him in his madim, his olive green IDF uniform,
on those days when he provides counseling to some of the soldiers who are
suffering the effects of having witnessed the unspeakable horrors of the
battlefield. In this, he is fulfilling the role that the Netziv attributes to
the tribe of Yissachar. In Moshe’s brachot to the tribes, the Netziv
understands Yissachar’s tents as being army tents, with Yissachar bringing
Torah and tefillah to the field of battle.5 Likewise, Rav
Sobol brings his perspectives of Torah and tefillah to IDF soldiers who
are hurting from their experiences in combat.
*
* *
Another special aspect of living in
Israel is the privilege of speaking Ivrit (Hebrew). The Talmud
Yerushalmi and its commentators describe Ivrit as the most fitting
language for everyday human speech.6 While there is plenty of
English spoken in our neighborhood, we also have many opportunities to interact
in Hebrew. We function pretty well in Hebrew, but no one will ever confuse us
with native speakers. We feel that speaking Ivrit is part of the
experience of the kibbutz galui’ot, the ingathering of our exiles. Eliezer
ben Yehuda began his reincarnation of Hebrew as a language for modern speech
about 150 years ago. Ever since then, it has developed exponentially, with new
words and new slang constantly being created, much of which has its origins in
the religious texts we are familiar with. In our view, modern Hebrew is endowed
with a vitality and energy reflecting the State in which it is spoken. When we
went to the Ayalon Institute (aka The Bullet Factory) where members of the
Haganah manufactured over two million bullets under the noses of the British
(who were preventing arms shipments to the Jews at the end of the Mandate
period), the instructions for bullet-making were in Hebrew. Likewise, at the
Palmach Museum in Tel Aviv, we observed that the War of Independence was fought
in Hebrew. Just a few decades after it had been raised from the dead, lashon
hakodesh was being used to create a Jewish State and facilitate the return
of Jews to the Land that Hashem gave us as a heritage. It is exciting to be a
part of this scene!
Ki mi’Tzion tetzei Torah. It is inspiring to participate in shiurim
given by Israeli Torah scholars whose depth and breadth of knowledge and
creativity are unparalleled. We also enjoy taking trips around the country with
those steeped in knowledge of Tanach, Mishna, and Jewish history. Tying
together the geography of Israel with Tanach provides new insights into texts
we thought we already knew. We have benefited from programs offered by Matan,
OU Israel, Midreshet Orot Techiya in Modi’in, independent tour guides, and
several local shuls.
Even the fruits and vegetables
grown in Israel are special. Fresh and flavorful, we not only enjoy their taste
but also enjoy their spiritual benefits. As the Bach on Orach Chaim Siman
208 says, the fruits of Eretz Yisrael contain kedusha (holiness) which a
person ingests when he or she eats the produce.
On a more practical note, we are
grateful that our employment situation is good. Myrna continues to work from
Israel as a CPA/tax adviser for the firm where she has been employed for many
years. Ron is working as a consultant, using his expertise in defense
technologies and underwater acoustics. His employment story is a bit of a saga
and a cautionary tale for those who hold security clearances in the U.S. When
we arrived in Israel, Ron had a job offer from an Israeli defense
contractor. However, Israel’s Ministry of Defense, cautious after the
Pollard debacle, would not allow him to be employed by this contractor due to
his past clearances. As a result, it took some time for Ron’s employment to
materialize, but in the end, he found work in his field.
*
* *
There are countless daily
experiences that make life in Israel exceptional, from the incredible Jewish
geography experiences to the person in front of you in the supermarket line
sharing a recipe for preparing the beets you happen to have in your shopping
cart. We would like to close with a few vignettes:
When we first made aliyah,
Ron was coming out of our building, when a boy about eight years old
interrupted his soccer game in the courtyard, came over, and asked Ron if we
had made aliyah. When Ron answered yes, the boy shook Ron’s hand and
wished us mazal tov. We have enjoyed watching this boy grow into a young
man.
About the same time, Myrna was on
the phone with Bezeq (the major phone and internet company in Israel) nervously
requesting internet service. When she apologized for her Hebrew by way of
explaining that she was a new olah, the representative stopped the
business discussion immediately and said in a slow, clear Hebrew: “First of
all, welcome to Israel!” Needless to say, the rest of the conversation went
well, and we became Bezeq customers.
Another time, Ron was coming back
from KSYM and saw a bus that listed as its destination “Tishrei/Cheshvan.” Ron
had never seen this bus in the neighborhood, and thought it amazing that the
bus company would be teaching the mussar that we should take the
spirituality of Tishrei into Cheshvan and the rest of the year. Ron excitedly
told this to Myrna, who explained: “There is a neighborhood in Modi’in where
the streets are named after the months of the Jewish year. Tishrei/Cheshvan is
the last stop for that line.” Perhaps this is so, but we have never seen that
bus in our neighborhood since then. Moreover, we have not had the same sort of
experience looking at MTA buses in Baltimore!
So, that is how we got here, and
that is why we stay. We hope that slowly but surely our family, and many Jews
in chutz la’aretz, will join us here as well. To quote Yehoshua and
Calev, “Tova ha’aretz me’od me’od,” the Land is very, very good.
1 See
www.VeryGoodNewsIsrael.blogspot.com to read and subscribe.[EB1]
2 Allusion to Rabbi Yissocher Frand: Listen
to Your Messages and Other Observations on Contemporary Jewish Life;
Mesorah publications Ltd., 1999
3 See Sefer Devarim for
numerous references to the Land. We also recommend Em Habanim Semeicha on
Eretz Yisrael, Redemption, and Unity by Harav Yisachar Shlomo Teichtal;
English Translation published by Kol Mevaser Publications, 2000.
4 See Rambam’s Mishneh Torah, Hilchot
Melachim U’Milchamot 5:1.
5 HaEmek Davar, Devarim 33:18
6 Yerushalmi, Shabbat 1:3
[EB1]Is
this misspelled? (good instead of god)





