The Israeli elections have taken place, and I will begin by presenting the results so you can see them:
Jewish Right, 53 seats: Likud
27, Otzma Yehudit 7, Religious Zionists 6, United Torah Judaism (UTJ) 7, Shas
6.
Jewish Left, 48 seats: Yashar
21, Beyachad 12 (Bennett 7, Lapid 5), Democrats 8, Yisrael Beiteinu 7
Arab Parties, 19 seats: Joint
List 11, Ra’am 8.
In the 2022
elections, by contrast, those same right-wing parties won 64 seats, the Jewish
left wing won 46, and the Arabs won 10 seats.
In terms of the
Jewish vote, the Right did very well, winning 53 seats to 48 for the Left. Yet
there were also 18 Arab votes, more than there ever have been, and since 61 are
needed to make a government, that changes everything.
*
* *
These elections
have left a bad taste in my mouth. They are troubling to anyone who loves the
State of Israel, the Torah of Israel, the People of Israel, and the Land of
Israel. It is hard for me to talk about these elections or even to think about
them. I don’t like the message, but I have been asked to be the messenger.
In the evening,
when the results were first clear to us, our new Chief Rabbi of Kiryat Arba,
Rabbi Avraham Yitzchak Schwartz, began his daily Mishna Brura class by saying
simply, “Let us celebrate the election results by learning some Mishna Brura.”
Admittedly, there was some sarcasm there, but also a veiled reference to the
common Jewish idea that exile is part of redemption, that suffering is a
necessary preparation for rejoicing. We suffer and make our mistakes now so
that we can rejoice later. It’s not the first time.
The results were
not the ones most religious Jews hoped for, even if they were anticipated. So
why did the Right fail? At least three reasons:
First, many right-wing
voters, both liberal religious Zionist voters and less religious Shas voters
decided to “be fair” after October 7th and “give someone else a
chance,” as though this were a high school GO election. This was despite the
warnings and protestations of those around them about the existential dangers
involved.
Second, in 2022,
the left-wing Meretz party did not pass the voting threshold and lost their
four seats, whereas this time, it was the right wing that lost four seats
through Ofer Winter not passing the threshold.
Third, and last,
there was the alarming rise in Arab votes from 10 to 18. It should be noted
that veteran journalist Ayala Hasson recently lost her job as a newswoman for
claiming that Arab voter fraud, fueled by bribe money from Qatar, led to much
larger Arab voter turnout than in the previous election. When she tried to
report her findings, they were rejected by – guess who? – Attorney General Gali
Baharav-Miara, the same person who rejected and overturned the Likud deal that
would have given the chareidim draft deferments during the past four
years.
I suggested before
the election that the two right-wing “Korach” figures, Avigdor Liberman and
Naftali Bennett, would not dare rely on Arab votes to create a coalition. They
both swore that they would not. I was wrong. They are both headed for a “government
of change,” one in which Mansour Abbas of the Arab Ra’am party is made a part
of the coalition, with access to security discussions. The more extreme Joint
List Arab party will not join the coalition but will quietly give its support
from outside, enabling the government to be formed, even if it is officially a “minority
government.”
A few days ago,
Avigdor Liberman was asked by a right-wing Channel 14 reporter, “How can you,
who once led the right wing, lend a hand to terror supporters by relying on
them in this election?”
Here is my
paraphrase of Liberman’s response: “You Channel 14 people are not the right
wing! You serve one man, not the right wing. You are the biggest liars – not
me. Our goal is to get rid of Netanyahu. Nothing else.”
*
* *
There you have it!
Getting rid of Netanyahu is the goal. Nothing else matters. The country can go
to hell. Israel’s enemies can sit in the war room when Israel is planning a
battle. The main thing is that Netanyahu should be gotten rid of.
Bennett, although
he is lending his hand to this just as much, has remained much more circumspect.
He realizes that if he goes forward with joining the Arabs, no right-winger
will ever vote for him again, and his political career will be over.
To achieve their
goal, Liberman and Bennett are willing to rely on the abstentions of the Arab
Joint List, with its 11 seats, and to allow into the coalition the Arab Ra’am
party, with its 8 seats. This will give them 56 recommendation votes, compared
to 46 for Netanyahu. (The chareidi UTJ party did not recommend either
side.) Before the elections, all three men – Eisenkot, Bennett, and Liberman –
swore not to rely on the Arab votes.
As an alternative
to joining with the Arabs, they might convince the UTJ party with its 7 seats
to support them in exchange for their receiving financial support and draft
exemptions. We will see where this goes. In any event, the left wing has
announced that now is not the time to fight over conscription. (They know that
they, anyway, will not be able to rely on the Arabs to force the enlargement of
the Israeli army with chareidi soldiers.)
For a taste of the
Arabs’ attitudes, the Ra’am party has offered a lukewarm condemnation of Hamas
after hemming and hawing about it, and the Joint List, which is not trying to
be part of the government, is worse. The day after the election, the Joint List
called for the establishment of a Palestinian State in all of Judea and
Samaria, with the expulsion of 750,000 Jews from there. And they walked out on
the singing of Hatikva. Ra’am did not. (What would happen if UTJ walked out on
Hatikva…?)
In response to the
possibility of bringing the Arabs into the government, Almog Cohen of the Likud
Party and formerly of Itamar Ben Gvir’s Otzma Yehudit party, threatened to
hound all the religious Knesset members in the left-wing parties if a left-wing
government relies on terror-supporting Arab parties. These include Yoram Cohen,
Matan Kahana, Elazar Stern, Elyasaf Peretz, and Hili Tropper from Gadi Eisenkot’s
party, and Naftali Bennett from his own Beyachad party. Cohen threatened that
protesters would stand outside the synagogues where these men pray and make it
impossible for them to participate in communal prayer as long as they are part
of a government that relies on the quiet agreement of pro-terrorist Arab
parties. At least four of these men are honest, idealistic men with a
conscience (even if they are misguided elitists) and may change sides and turn
against the Left. Or not.
*
* *
It is said that
Netanyahu, the inveterate chess player, wanted Eisenkot to have the first
chance to form a government. He was hoping for the left wing to flounder in its
attempts, and then he would be given a chance and would be able to nobly offer
his Arab-free “unity” deal. Alternatively, Israel would go to new elections
and, 1) Arab polling places would be more carefully watched to catch bribery,
2) Thousands of left wing yordim who flew to Israel to vote would not
fly in again, and 3) liberal right-wing voters would see how much damage they
had done by voting for the Left and would return to the Right. Generally known
as a political genius, Netanyahu may have nevertheless underestimated the
degree to which the anyone-but-Bibi group detests him.
Of course,
anything can happen. The news is very fluid. The last thing I want to do is to
drive 20,000 Baltimoreans into despair. Anyway, on the specific issue of the chareidi
draft, I think I have provided some sort of comfort. The Left has decided not
to push that point right now. When the Likud was in power, forcing the chareidi
draft was the be-all and end-all. Suddenly, “for some reason,” the issue is less
important to them.
*
* *
I will end with two brief Torah thoughts that
can help us to view matters in perspective (and help me to be less sarcastic):
First, let us not
forget Israel’s arrival at the bitter waters of Marah (Shemot 15:22-25). The Chasam
Sofer explains that Moshe threw a piece of poison wood into the poison water,
and against all logic, the double-poison combination created something healthy
and pleasant to drink. This was a double miracle.
Here, in Israel’s
election, we are once more faced with many types of poison operating together.
Only Hashem has the ability to create something sweet out of it, as He has improbably
done so often in the past.
Second, this past
week, Shabbat Chayei Sarah, with thousands of others, I brought my four guests
down to Hebron for vatikin, and we all learned Sfat Emet with my
friend Yisrael Ze’ev. Yisrael taught us the first ma’amar from 1896.
There, the Gerrer Rebbe quoted the Rashi on Bereishit 23:1, which states that
all the years of Sarah’s life were “equal in their goodness.” As the Gerrer
Rebbe explains, Sarah was blessed with equanimity, the ability to calmly view
everything that happened to her, all the ups and downs of life positively, and
passing that test was one of the keys to her own greatness and perfection.
Yisrael told me
that he chose that paragraph because of the elections I have just mentioned.
May we learn from Sarah’s example!





